Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Deviously Deviant GoldenCritique-ClubUnited States Recent Activity Deviant for 1 Year
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 96 Deviations
11 Comments
4,312 Pageviews

Updates and ideas

Tue Oct 13, 2009, 8:28 AM
Time for a couple updates, and questions for our members! If you could take the time to read through this and give us some feedback, that would be great :)

First of all, the club has a new affiliate: :iconcritique-it:
It operates a bit differently than this club; at *Critique-It they have a specific group of people in charge of giving out critiques (at ~GoldenCritique-Club, the source of critiques come from the members and maintainers). Check it out if you're interested!

Second, DeviantArt seems to be having some submission problems on certain accounts. There is a forum post here: [link]
We do have a submission waiting to go, but it looks like we can't upload it to the club until the bug is fixed.

Thirdly, we'd like some feedback on extra things to do with the club! For instance:

Favorites
Right now, the club's favorites are empty. I was thinking of adding some good tutorials/reference guides. What would you like to see there?


Features
Some clubs will use their journal to occasionally feature artists or individual deviations. We could do a feature of a random active member, or feature non-member submissions that have critique requested, but hasn't gotten any critiques.
I think in order to post thumbnails, the club needs a paid account (which it doesn't have at the moment). So if people do not feel very strongly on the features, we'll hold off on that idea for now.


Contests or collaborations
Would anyone be interested in entering a club contest? What kind of a contest would you be interested in? Some possibilities are:
-design a new icon/ID for the club
-a self improvement contest, similar to the "Kick your own ass" contest that DA held a few months ago.
-a tutorial contest
-a group collaboration, where one person started a drawing, then handed it off to the next person to work on, etc. This could be just one collaborative drawing, or it could be more like an exquisite cadaver (see explanation and examples: [link] [link] [link])







_______

Hello! Welcome to the Golden Critique Club. The purpose of this club is to allow members of DeviantArt to submit works they wish to receive critiques on as well as allowing anyone to critique other member's submissions. Membership is open to anyone with a DeviantArt account!
For more information, please see these journals:

How to join: [link]
General rules: [link]
Submission guidelines: [link]
Giving and receiving critiques: [link]

Maintainers: :iconalvonia: :iconvioletice:

Members list: [link]


Affiliates:
:iconcritique-it:
:iconclubdirectory:

deviantID

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:iconshrimpmuffin:
So how does one get some critique around here? Heavens knows I need it.

--
I go on spacebook and myface! Icon by EurukaTT
:icongoldencritique-club:
If you'd like to join, watch the club and follow the instructions here on how to submit something: [link]

If you're able to critique any of the recent submission that would be great (since critiques are member driven). If you have any questions, let us know!
:iconshrimpmuffin:
Sounds great! Thanks!

--
I go on spacebook and myface! Icon by EurukaTT
:iconlexis-l:
Do you critique works still in progress? I'm just starting out and need to make my existing pieces stand out, I'd love some guidance through the process and to know that I'm going about things the right way!
:icongoldencritique-club:
Yes, work in progress submissions are definitely accepted :)

Just let us know if you'd like to become a member of the club
:iconlexis-l:
Definitely - pass me a pen and show me the dotted line! Haha :)
:icongoldencritique-club:
awesome! I'll add you to the member list shortly :)

If you'd like to submit something, just check out the submission rules here: [link]
:iconmau506sk:
I saw that there's a new critique feature in DA, will it be used in the club? :?

--
Contest under reconstruction, more details soon, please sorry for the disorder

-----

Visita mi blog de anime y deportes, "Otaku Deportivo" [link]
:icongoldencritique-club:
I don't think so, because it's subscription only, and at this point we don't plan on subscribing (both of us maintainers already pay at our main accounts).

If someone submits an image for critique, they are encouraged to allow critiques on the one in their gallery if they have a subscription, but it's not required :)
:iconmau506sk:
Oh, forget it! I saw that it's a subscriber feature only :tears:

--
Contest under reconstruction, more details soon, please sorry for the disorder

-----

Visita mi blog de anime y deportes, "Otaku Deportivo" [link]

Site Map